Q2 2023 Fund Flows: Equity Outflows, Money Market Influx, and Recession Jitters
As we cross the halfway mark of 2023, the narrative of the stock market has been characterized by the Magnificent Seven powering major indices forward. The S&P 500 is now flirting with its all-time highs at the same time the Bloomberg US Aggregate is continuing its rally.
YoY inflation retreated to a more manageable 2.97% in June, a significant downtick from its multi-decade record 9% peak just a year ago. And after hiking interest rates for 15 straight months, the Federal Reserve appears to be easing off the gas after pausing hikes in June. However, the central bank anticipates two more hikes before 2023 wraps up.
The VIX has remained relatively subdued, hitting its lowest level since the pre-pandemic period.
Nevertheless, recessionary fears persist, with the predicted chances of an economic downturn hovering at their highest level since the 1980s. But it’s not all storm clouds on the horizon as consumer sentiment is soaring to levels not seen since September 2021.
Between fund flows, consumer sentiment, and reducing inflation, the economy seems caught between recovery and caution, underscored by strong market performance mixed with apprehension of a potential recession.
In a reflection of the economic uncertainties, investor behavior in the second quarter was characterized by a sustained preference for safety and liquidity. This manifested itself in the substantial $173.2B inflow into Money Market funds during Q2 2023, albeit at a reduced pace from the Q1 influx. The preference for these low-risk vehicles underscores the ongoing apprehension among investors despite signs of economic recovery and market gains.
Fund flows are the net cash inflow into a fund (purchases) or net outflow from a fund (redemptions). Irrespective of fund performance, when a mutual fund or ETF has positive fund flows (or net issuances for ETFs) in a given period, that fund’s managers have more cash to buy more holdings. The opposite is also true: as fundholders sell shares, fund managers sell out of positions and use the cash to pay redemptions.
This means that fund flow data can indicate higher or lower demand for different asset types, depending on which funds and categories have relatively large inflows or outflows.
Interested in receiving YCharts Fund Flow Reports? Subscribe here:
Mutual Fund Flows: Biggest Winners and Losers
While Money Market funds continued to attract the lion’s share of inflows in Q2 2023 with $173.2B, the fixed income space also witnessed considerable action. The appetite for stability was evident as Intermediate Core Bond and Intermediate Core-Plus Bond mutual funds saw significant quarterly inflows, with $27.2B and $19.2B, respectively. This trend suggests investors’ desire for relatively safer assets amid economic uncertainty.
In Q2 2023, investors demonstrated a continued transition from mutual funds to ETFs, most notably in equities. Despite their mutual fund counterparts experiencing significant outflows, Large Blend and Growth ETFs saw quarterly inflows of $57.9B and $8.8B, respectively. Additionally, Intermediate Core Bond funds maintained consistent appeal across both investment vehicles, emphasizing their attractiveness amidst market uncertainty.
The table below summarizes the nine equity-style boxes’ performance along with combined ETF and mutual fund flows.
Despite positive returns across all equity styles, assets flowed out of equity funds of every style but two. In the large-cap segment, Blend stood out with strong inflows of $35B. Yet, despite the outperformance of Growth that delivered 11% returns, flow data suggests that returns in the first half of the year have still not convinced investors back to equities fully.
Investor Caution Grows as Outflows Hit High-Performing Sectors
Likely buoyed by the performances from major tech names, investors have continued to pivot towards growth-oriented sectors. Consequently, funds weighted toward Technology and Communication Services saw quarterly inflows of $2.3B and $1.8B, respectively. On the other end of the spectrum, the leader-to-laggard shifts continued for Energy and Health Care funds in Q2, seeing an exodus of $7B and $2.7B, respectively.
The surge in inflows for Intermediate Core Bond and Intermediate Core-Plus Bond funds poses a prime opportunity for wholesalers with products in these categories. As advisors increasingly discuss these asset categories with their clients, you have a unique opportunity to deliver valuable insights. By utilizing the Fund Screener to uncover rival funds within these categories and dissect their strengths and weaknesses, you can convincingly position your offerings as superior alternatives, seamlessly integrating your insights into advisors’ ongoing conversations with their clients.
In the equity space, Large Growth funds experienced considerable outflows during Q2, suggesting that investors are reevaluating their strategies in the growth space. Utilize the Scenarios or Stress Tests to highlight your Large Growth fund’s performance over time or during similar market environments.
Proactively using fund flow data and other various tools at your disposal can help position your funds. By aligning your products with market trends and conversations advisors are having with their clients, you can emphasize your funds’ unique value in today’s market. For a more detailed discussion surrounding fund flows, check out a replay of our latest fund flow webinar.